Apply each of the following questions to the paper you’ve selected to read. Provide thorough and thoughtful answers so the author can easily and appropriately revise.

Who is the main audience of this paper?

What is the main idea presented herein?

What information does the reader need to know about the idea for it to make sense?

Are examples clear and appropriate?

Is evidence or support for any claims provided?

Is the topic appropriate to the writing assignment? Does it need to be more general? More focused?

Are writer’s points organized in a logical way?